| Prototable11 of 11 | Magic Set Editor1 of 11 | |
|---|---|---|
| Runs in the browser, nothing to install | Yes | NoDesktop program |
| Players join free from a link, no account | Yes | NoExport to play |
| Design cards from templates | Yes | PartlyFor existing games |
| Import spreadsheets, images, PDFs and TTS sheets | Yes | No |
| 3D table with physics dice | Yes | NoNo table |
| Edit a card mid-game and everyone sees it at once | Yes | NoExport again |
| No-code macros and automations | Yes | No |
| Record playtests, with notes and player feedback | Yes | No |
| Review changes card by card, keep or discard | Yes | No |
| Print-and-play PDFs | Yes | PartlyPrints cards and exports images |
| A free plan | Yes | Yes |
Yes Partly No, or not in their docs
In detail
| Prototable | Magic Set Editor | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A tool for designing your own game and playtesting it. | A card editor for custom sets, mainly for Magic, with community templates for other games such as Yu-Gi-Oh!. |
| Where it runs | In the browser, on a laptop, desktop, iPad or phone. Nothing to install. | A program you install on your computer. |
| Price | Free for two games, with 2 players a room. Designer, with everything, is $99 a year or $15 a month. | Free. |
| Making cards | Built in: card templates with your own fields, fonts, colors and icons, plus tokens, boards, dice and counters. | Pick a game’s template and fill in the fields. The look comes from existing frames, and you can build custom templates with more work. |
| Playtesting | On the same table you design on. Share a link and play. | Export sets to LackeyCCG or Cockatrice, and play there. |
| Changing a card | Edit a card during the game and every copy updates at once, on the table, in hands and in decks. | Change the card and export again. |
| Printing | PDF print sheets with cut guides and bleed, Letter to Tabloid, and a sprite sheet PNG. | Prints cards and exports images, and shows graphs of a set. |
Where Magic Set Editor is stronger
- Exact frames for Magic and other existing games
- Free, with a long-running community
- Statistics and graphs for a whole set
Questions
Is Prototable a good alternative to Magic Set Editor?
Yes, if you are designing your own game with your own layout, and want to play it from a link. You can also test custom cards against real decks at your own table. Prototable has all 11 of the capabilities we compare; Magic Set Editor has 1.
When is Magic Set Editor the better choice?
When you want custom cards that look exactly like an existing game, and you play them in Cockatrice or LackeyCCG. It is stronger at: exact frames for Magic and other existing games; free, with a long-running community; statistics and graphs for a whole set.
How does Magic Set Editor's price compare with Prototable's?
Magic Set Editor: Free. Prototable: Free for two games, with 2 players a room. Designer, with everything, is $99 a year or $15 a month.
Can I move my game from Magic Set Editor to Prototable?
Prototable imports a spreadsheet or CSV, a folder of images, PDFs made for print, or a Tabletop Simulator card sheet cut into cards. Players join free from a link.
Looking wider? Magic Set Editor alternatives for designers.
Sources
Checked against Magic Set Editor’s own site and docs in November 2026:Magic Set Editor forum, MTG Wiki: Magic Set Editor. Tools change; if something here is out of date, tell us on Discord and we’ll fix it.
More comparisons: Tabletop Simulator, Dustin's Designer Den, Screentop, Tabletopia, playingcards.io, Tabletop Playground, Dextrous, Component.Studio, nanDECK, ShuffleKit, Canva, Squib, Tabletop Creator.